Companies investing in digital signage face an important choice. They need to decide between using external media players or System on Chip (SoC) displays.
Each option has its own benefits and drawbacks based on the application, scale, and environment. This guide looks closely at these choices. It offers insights into their features, advantages, and limitations to help you make a smart decision.
What is a Digital Signage Media Player?
A digital signage media player is a device. It shows content such as videos, images, and text on a display screen. These players connect to the screen using HDMI, DisplayPort, or other standard connections. They are often mounted on the back of the display or in a nearby cabinet.
Media players come in different sizes and processing power levels. They also work with various operating systems and software. These players act as the “brain” of a digital signage system. They manage and update content, handle scheduling, and allow for remote control.
Digital signage media players are ideal for multi-display environments, complex content types, and applications that require robust processing power or specialized software. They also support greater flexibility in terms of software compatibility and display customization.
Leading Operating Systems for Signage Media Players
The choice of operating system is a crucial aspect, as it dictates the compatibility, security, and functionality of a digital signage solution. Here are the leading operating systems powering today’s digital signage media players:
- Android: Widely popular due to its flexibility and developer-friendly platform, Android allows for extensive app support and customization. Many digital signage solutions use Android media players for easy integration with a wide variety of software.
- Windows: Known for reliability and compatibility with enterprise software, Windows-powered media players are commonly used for high-end or enterprise-level signage needs. Windows provides robust security features and supports complex applications.
- Linux: Open-source and highly customizable, Linux-based media players are popular among businesses needing unique or proprietary software installations. Linux is stable, secure, and low-cost, making it a favorite for companies that need highly specialized solutions.
- Chrome OS: Google’s Chrome OS has made headway in digital signage, especially for straightforward, cloud-based applications. Chrome OS devices offer security, remote manageability, and cost-efficiency.
- Proprietary Systems: Some manufacturers develop their own operating systems tailored for digital signage. These proprietary systems may offer streamlined performance and enhanced reliability but are often more restrictive in terms of app compatibility and updates.
Leading Manufacturers of Digital Signage Media Players
Several manufacturers lead the market, each offering distinct advantages in terms of processing power, design, and compatibility:
- BrightSign: Known for reliable, high-performance media players with excellent customer support and a dedicated operating system, BrightSign is ideal for high-demand environments.
- Intel: Intel’s NUC (Next Unit of Computing) devices are compact, powerful, and capable of handling intensive digital signage applications. They’re highly compatible with both Windows and Linux.
- AOPEN: AOPEN produces rugged, durable media players suitable for 24/7 applications and outdoor settings. Their media players often use Chrome OS, making them a good choice for businesses integrated with Google’s ecosystem.
- Samsung’s Tizen Box: Samsung offers a Tizen-based external media player that pairs well with their displays but can also work with other brands. This product line is known for its streamlined performance and ease of integration with Samsung’s SoC displays.
- Raspberry Pi: For budget-conscious setups, the Raspberry Pi offers an open-source, versatile option. Although lower in processing power, the Pi has become popular in smaller installations and educational environments.
Each manufacturer has carved out a niche based on unique offerings, whether it’s robust operating systems, ease of use, or hardware flexibility. Selecting the right media player provider depends on the specific needs and scale of your digital signage network.
What is a System on Chip (SoC) Display?
A System on Chip (SoC) display is a screen with a media player built into it. The SoC display has a processor that plays and manages content. It often uses an operating system like Android or Tizen. SoC displays are designed to make setup easier and reduce cables. This makes them ideal for businesses with simple signage needs or limited space for extra devices.
These all-in-one solutions are efficient and space-saving, especially in environments with minimal content demands. They’re also advantageous in cases where installation and maintenance simplicity are critical.
Pro’s and Cons of Using SoC Displays for Digital Signage
Advantages of SoC Displays:
- Streamlined Setup: With no external media player required, SoC displays are easier to install and often take up less space, making them suitable for smaller or more constrained environments.
- Reduced Hardware: Fewer cables, adapters, and mounting equipment are needed, resulting in a cleaner and more organized installation.
- Lower Maintenance: Fewer hardware components mean less potential for technical issues. Maintenance is often simpler, with fewer parts to troubleshoot or replace.
- Cost-Effective for Basic Applications: For businesses with simple signage needs, SoC displays can offer a more budget-friendly solution, as they reduce the need for additional hardware purchases.
- Integrated Power Management: SoC displays often come with energy-efficient designs that can help businesses manage power consumption more effectively.
Disadvantages of SoC Displays:
- Limited Processing Power: Compared to dedicated external media players, the built-in processors of SoC displays may lack the power to handle complex content or multiple high-resolution screens.
- Compatibility Constraints: SoC displays often run proprietary or limited operating systems, which may restrict the use of certain third-party apps or content management systems (CMS).
- Less Flexibility in Upgrades: With external media players, upgrades are as simple as replacing the media player. SoC displays, however, may require a complete screen replacement to achieve significant performance improvements.
- Dependence on Manufacturer-Specific Software: Many SoC displays are designed to work best with the manufacturer’s software, which may limit the flexibility to customize or adapt to other systems.
- Restricted Remote Management: Some SoC displays allow remote management, but they often lack the control and customization of external media players. This is especially true for larger deployments.
Leading Manufacturers of SoC Displays for Digital Signage
The market for SoC displays is led by well-known brands in the display industry. Each brand has its own strengths and special platforms.
- Samsung: Samsung’s SoC displays use the Tizen OS, known for strong processing capabilities and compatibility with Samsung’s Smart Signage Platform (SSSP). Samsung is a leading choice for retail and corporate environments where display quality and brand reputation are priorities.
- LG: LG’s SoC displays run on their WebOS platform, providing stability and ease of use. LG’s displays are highly popular in retail, hospitality, and healthcare, where SoC simplicity and visual quality are essential.
- Sony: Sony’s SoC displays are Android-based, offering compatibility with various CMS solutions and a user-friendly interface. Sony’s reputation for display quality makes it a choice for professional environments, including conference rooms and entertainment venues.
- Philips: Philips’ SoC displays run on the Android OS. They are flexible and easy to integrate with many CMS platforms. Philips displays are popular in education, healthcare, and retail. In these fields, high-quality visuals and reliable performance are very important.
Each of these manufacturers is respected for reliability, durability, and visual quality, ensuring that their SoC displays can handle demanding signage needs with minimal maintenance requirements.
Book a free consultation today
Comparing SoC Displays with External Signage Players
System on Chip displays and traditional digital signage setups each have their distinct advantages. SoC displays feature an integrated design, which often simplifies installation and reduces hardware clutter. On the other hand, traditional setups usually involve separate components, like media players, providing more customization options.
When considering performance, traditional setups might have the upper hand. External media players generally offer superior processing power, handling complex media tasks more effectively. This makes them suitable for environments where high-quality, dynamic content is crucial.
Maintenance approaches differ significantly between the two. SoC displays often have fewer parts to manage, leading to potentially lower maintenance needs. However, if an issue arises, traditional setups allow for individual component repairs, avoiding full system replacements. This modularity can be a significant benefit for businesses with specific maintenance strategies.
Lastly, while SoC displays promote energy efficiency and compactness, traditional setups can be more flexible. Businesses with specific signage requirements may prefer the adaptability of traditional systems. Here’s a quick list of key differences:
- SoC displays: Integrated and compact, energy-efficient
- Traditional setups: Modular, customizable, potentially more powerful
Final Verdict: Media Players vs. SoC Displays
If your company values flexibility, scalability, and processing power, investing in external media players is the ideal choice. They offer robust performance and adaptability to complex digital signage needs.
For companies with simple content requirements, limited space, or a constrained budget, SoC displays provide a streamlined
